By Sergei Mochtchenkov, CFA ·
For years, an SBA 7(a) acquisition loan could close on a business valuation, tax returns and the lender's own analysis of the seller's numbers. That changed on October 1, 2026. Under SBA's updated Standard Operating Procedure, SOP 50 10 8.1, larger change of ownership loans now need an independent quality of earnings (QoE) report as well.
I'm Sergei Mochtchenkov, a CFA Charterholder, and I prepare buy-side quality of earnings reports for SBA acquisitions. This article walks through what the requirement says, which deals it covers, what the report has to contain, who can prepare it, and how buyers, independent sponsors and lenders can plan around it without delaying closing.
Where the requirement comes from
The rule sits in Appendix 15 of SOP 50 10 8.1, Lender and Development Company Loan Programs, the SBA's origination manual for 7(a) and 504 loans. Appendix 15 covers change of ownership transactions.
SBA first published SOP 50 10 8.1 on August 14, 2026, then replaced it with a version containing technical policy updates on September 25, 2026, before it took effect. As NAGGL summarized, the updated version applies to loans receiving an SBA loan number on or after October 1, 2026, while loans numbered on or before September 30 stay under SOP 50 10 8. If you saved a copy of the August text, work from the September version instead; the two differ on points that matter for QoE, including whether a buyer's own report can be used.
Which deals need a QoE
The SOP states that "for Business Expansion and Initial Acquisition transactions where the Purchase Price ... is equal to or greater than $3 million, the Lender must also obtain a Quality of Earnings (QoE) in addition to the required Business Valuation."
Three details decide whether your deal is in scope:
- Transaction type. Initial Acquisitions (a buyer acquiring a business) and Business Expansions (an existing business acquiring another) are covered. Owner Buyout and ESOP and Cooperative transactions are not, because, in SBA's words, the existing owners "retain operational knowledge of the business."
- Business Purchase Price, not loan amount. The threshold is "determined before the application of buyer equity, seller debt, or other financing sources." A deal priced at $3 million or more is covered even if the 7(a) loan itself is smaller.
- Real estate is carved out. The SOP defines Business Purchase Price as the price in the purchase agreement less the appraised value of owner-occupied commercial real estate in the deal. A transaction involving an owner-occupied Special Purpose Property does not need a QoE regardless of price, though the valuation and other diligence rules still apply.
Below the threshold, nothing stops a lender from asking for a QoE or a proof of cash under its own credit policy, and many buyers commission one anyway to protect their equity.
What the report must contain
Appendix 15 is more specific than most lender diligence checklists. It describes a QoE as "a financial due diligence report that examines the reliability, sustainability, and accuracy of a business's historical and projected earnings," and sets out minimum content.
A four-way reconciliation. The analysis "must reconcile the business's accountant-prepared financial statements, tax returns, internal financial statements, and IRS transcript data to produce a normalized, adjusted earnings figure that reflects recurring, arm's-length operations." Small businesses often have gaps between these sources, and explaining those gaps is a large part of the work.
A Cash Proof. The QoE "must include a Cash Proof," defined as an analysis that "reconstructs cash receipts and disbursements by reconciling bank statement data to the income statement and tax return for each period under review." It must cover the trailing 12 months and the last two fiscal years, with reduced scope if the business has operated for less than two years. My guide to proof of cash explains how the reconciliation works.
Documented add-backs. The report "must identify and document all add-backs and adjustments to the seller's reported earnings," including non-recurring items, above- or below-market owner compensation, related-party transactions, deferred maintenance, and differences between cash-basis and accrual-basis reporting. That list goes beyond what many broker packages present. Downward adjustments count too. See the EBITDA add-backs buyers reject for the ones that most often fail.
Revenue sustainability. The QoE must assess "customer concentration risk, contract continuity, and the likelihood that existing revenue and margins will be maintained post-sale." This is where an earnings number becomes a credit view: will the cash flow survive the change of owner?
How lenders use the QoE
The QoE is not a box to tick. The SOP says the lender "must use the earnings from the QoE in the Debt Service Coverage (DSC) determination and retain the QoE report in the credit file." Elsewhere, Appendix 15 adds that if the resulting DSC "does not support the business valuation and proposed debt structure, the loan amount must be reduced accordingly."
The minimum DSC in Appendix 15 is 1.25:1 for Initial Acquisitions and 1.15:1 for Business Expansions. When the QoE removes add-backs that the seller's numbers relied on, DSC can fall below those levels, and the gap has to be closed with more equity, a lower price or a smaller loan. Learning that during underwriting is far better than learning it after a first year of thin cash flow.
The QoE also does not replace the business valuation. Both are required for in-scope deals. The valuation supports the price; the QoE tests whether the earnings behind the price are real and recurring.
Who can prepare an SBA QoE
This is one of the most common questions about the rule. The SOP requires that the QoE "be performed by an independent, experienced financial professional" and "be conducted for the benefit of the Lender." It "must not be prepared by or for the seller."
Notice what the text does not do. For business valuations, Appendix 15 lists the accreditations a "Qualified Source" must hold: ASA, CBA, ABV, CVA or BCA. For the QoE, it names no credential and does not limit the work to CPAs. That means a CFA charterholder, like any other financial professional, can perform the QoE under the SOP if they are independent of the transaction and experienced in this work. A credential alone is not enough, and the lender still decides which providers it will accept.
The September technical update also addressed buyers who start diligence early. The SOP now says lenders "may elect to have that report reviewed by one of their approved vendors to help mitigate costs," with the review findings kept in the loan file, and that the lender "may not rely upon a QoE report prepared by another party without a review being performed by one of their vendors." In practice, if you commission a buy-side QoE before choosing a lender, ask early how that lender handles reliance and vendor review.
Timing: when the QoE must be engaged
Timing rules depend on how the loan is processed:
- Non-delegated submissions. If the application goes to SBA's Loan Guaranty Processing Center, "the business valuation and QoE must be submitted as part of the loan application."
- PLP lenders. Under Preferred Lender authority, the QoE may be completed after the SBA loan number is issued and before closing, but it "must have been formally engaged (i.e., a vendor must have been retained, and an engagement letter must be in place)" when the loan number is issued.
For buyers, the practical message is to line up the QoE right after the letter of intent is signed, not after the loan is approved. A Cash Proof needs monthly bank statements, general ledger detail, tax returns and payroll records for roughly three years, and sellers rarely have those in one place.
How buyers and sponsors should plan
A few steps reduce friction:
- Confirm scope with the lender first. Agree on who engages the provider, how the report will be relied on, and whether the lender requires a provider from its own vendor list.
- Request the data early. Bank statements for every account, tax returns, accountant-prepared statements, internal monthly financials, payroll reports and a customer revenue listing. Missing statements are a common cause of delay.
- Pressure-test the add-backs before the LOI is final. If the price rests on owner adjustments that cannot be documented, it is better to renegotiate early.
- Plan working capital at the same time. A QoE often surfaces seasonal swings and timing differences that also matter for the net working capital peg.
If you're new to the deliverable itself, start with what a quality of earnings report is. If you're working on an SBA deal now, my SBA acquisition financing work is built around these Appendix 15 requirements, and you can book a call to talk through scope and timing.
FAQ
Does every SBA acquisition now need a QoE?
No. The requirement applies to Initial Acquisitions and Business Expansions with a Business Purchase Price of $3 million or more, excluding owner-occupied real estate. Owner Buyouts and ESOP and Cooperative transactions are exempt, though lenders can still ask for one.
Is the $3 million threshold based on the loan size?
No. It is based on the Business Purchase Price, measured before buyer equity, seller notes or other financing.
Can the seller's sell-side QoE satisfy the requirement?
No. The SOP says the QoE "must not be prepared by or for the seller." A sell-side report can still help the seller prepare, but the lender needs a report done for its benefit.
Does the QoE preparer need to be a CPA?
The SOP does not require a specific credential for the QoE. It requires an independent, experienced financial professional working for the lender's benefit, so a CFA Charterholder with relevant experience can do the work. The separate business valuation does require one of the accreditations listed in Appendix 15.
Is a QoE an audit?
No. A QoE is financial due diligence, not an attest engagement, and it does not give an audit opinion. A QoE tests the earnings a buyer and lender rely on, while an audit tests whether the financial statements are fairly presented.