By Sergei Mochtchenkov, CFA ·
Most quality of earnings engagements do not slow down because the analysis is hard. They slow down because the data arrives late, in pieces, or in a form that does not reconcile. A buyer signs a letter of intent, the lender asks for a QoE, and then several weeks pass while the seller searches for bank statements from two years ago.
I'm Sergei Mochtchenkov, a CFA Charterholder, and I prepare quality of earnings reports for buyers, sellers and lenders in lower middle market and SBA-financed deals. This checklist sets out the documents a QoE typically needs, why each one matters, and how to organize them so fieldwork can start on day one.
If you are new to the deliverable, start with what a quality of earnings report is. This guide assumes you know the goal and want to get the data ready.
Why the checklist starts with SBA's rules
For SBA 7(a) acquisitions, the minimum content of a QoE is now written down. Appendix 15 of SBA SOP 50 10 8.1 says the analysis "must reconcile the business's accountant-prepared financial statements, tax returns, internal financial statements, and IRS transcript data," must include a Cash Proof covering the trailing 12 months and the last two fiscal years, and must document all add-backs and adjustments. My overview of the SBA quality of earnings requirement explains which deals are in scope.
Even when a deal is not SBA-financed, that list is a sensible baseline. A conventional lender, a private equity buyer or an independent sponsor will ask for much the same evidence. The checklist below is organized around it.
1. Financial statements
- Accountant-prepared financial statements for the last two or three fiscal years: compiled, reviewed or audited, whichever exists. Note which level of service the accountant provided.
- Internal monthly income statements and balance sheets for the same period and the year to date, from the accounting system.
- Trial balances at each fiscal year-end and at the most recent month-end.
- General ledger detail for every period under review, exported in a format that can be filtered (not a PDF).
Monthly detail matters because a QoE looks at trends, seasonality and one-time items within each year, not just annual totals. A business that only closes its books annually will need extra time.
2. Tax returns and IRS transcripts
- Federal business tax returns for the last two or three years, with all schedules.
- Owners' personal returns where the business is a pass-through and owner items flow through them.
- Signed IRS transcript authorization. SBA lenders typically verify tax data directly with the IRS. The IRS Income Verification Express Service is the channel lenders use to obtain transcripts with the taxpayer's consent.
- Sales tax and payroll tax filings, which provide an independent check on revenue and wages.
Differences between the tax return and the internal financials are normal, especially when the return is prepared on a cash basis and the books are on accrual. What matters is that each difference can be explained.
3. Bank and credit card statements
- Monthly statements for every business bank account, including closed accounts, for the full review period.
- Merchant processor statements (card payments, online payment platforms) for businesses that take card or online payments.
- Credit card statements for business cards.
- Loan statements for all debt, leases and lines of credit.
These are the raw material for the Cash Proof, which rebuilds receipts and disbursements from the bank and ties them to the income statement and tax return. Missing a single month, or a second account the bookkeeper forgot, can stall the reconciliation. My guide to proof of cash explains how the test works.
4. Revenue and customer data
- Revenue by customer for each year and the trailing 12 months, with the largest customers identified.
- Revenue by product, service line or location, if the business reports that way.
- Key customer contracts, including term, renewal and change-of-control clauses.
- Accounts receivable aging at each year-end and the latest month-end.
- Deferred revenue, deposits and backlog schedules, where relevant.
SBA's Appendix 15 asks the QoE to assess "customer concentration risk, contract continuity, and the likelihood that existing revenue and margins will be maintained post-sale." That assessment is impossible without customer-level data.
5. Payroll and owner compensation
- Payroll registers by employee, with roles and start dates.
- Quarterly payroll tax returns (Form 941) and annual W-2/W-3 summaries. The IRS Form 941 page describes the filing.
- Owner and family compensation, including salary, distributions, benefits and any personal expenses paid by the business.
- Contractor payments and 1099 summaries.
- Planned changes: open positions, recent hires, or raises the buyer will inherit.
Owner compensation is one of the largest adjustments in small-business deals, in both directions. In an S corporation, the IRS expects reasonable compensation for shareholder-employees, so an owner paid far below market can make EBITDA look higher than it will be once a replacement is hired.
6. Add-back support
Every proposed adjustment needs its own evidence:
- Invoices, contracts or settlement documents for one-time costs.
- Proof that personal expenses were personal, such as vehicle, travel or family phone costs, and that they will stop after closing.
- Related-party agreements, such as rent paid to an owner-controlled entity, with a view on market terms.
- Deferred maintenance and capital spending the business has postponed.
Sellers often present add-backs in a broker package without support. In a QoE, an add-back without evidence is usually removed. The adjustments that fail most often are covered in the EBITDA add-backs buyers reject.
7. Balance sheet and working capital
- Inventory listings and count procedures, with any reserves for slow-moving stock.
- Accounts payable aging and accrued expenses at each period-end.
- Fixed asset register and depreciation schedule.
- Debt and debt-like items: leases, customer deposits, unpaid taxes, deferred compensation.
This information supports the normalized working capital analysis and the peg in the purchase agreement. Monthly balance sheets are essential, because the peg is usually based on an average across the year.
8. Other diligence items
- Organizational documents and the ownership structure.
- Leases for premises and equipment.
- Insurance policies and any open claims.
- Pending litigation or regulatory matters.
- Management's forecast for the current year, if one exists, with its assumptions.
These are not all earnings items, but they often explain unusual entries in the ledger and affect how the buyer views the sustainability of earnings.
How to avoid delays
A few habits save the most time:
- Use one shared folder with the same structure as this checklist, and name files by period.
- Export ledgers and reports in spreadsheet format, not scanned PDFs.
- List every bank account up front, including closed ones, so nothing surfaces halfway through.
- Name a single contact on the seller's side who can answer accounting questions quickly.
- Raise known issues early. A reclassification or a missing month explained on day one costs far less time than one discovered in week three.
For sellers, gathering this file before going to market is the core of a QoE readiness review, and it shortens every buyer's diligence. For buyers, sending the list with the letter of intent sets expectations for the seller. If you have a deal coming up, you can book a call to talk through the data request and timing.
FAQ
How many years of data does a quality of earnings need?
Usually two to three fiscal years plus the trailing 12 months. For SBA 7(a) acquisitions in scope of Appendix 15, the Cash Proof must cover the trailing 12 months and the last two fiscal years, with reduced scope for businesses operating less than two years.
Who provides the documents, the buyer or the seller?
The seller holds almost all of the data. The buyer or lender engages the QoE provider, but the seller's cooperation decides how fast the work goes.
Can the QoE start before every document arrives?
Yes. Work usually starts with the financial statements, tax returns and bank statements, while customer, payroll and add-back support follow. Cash Proof work cannot finish until every bank statement is in.
Does a CFA charterholder prepare SBA quality of earnings reports?
SBA's SOP requires an independent, experienced financial professional working for the lender's benefit and does not limit QoE work to a particular credential, so a CFA Charterholder can perform it. The lender must still accept the provider and scope.
Is this the same checklist as an audit?
No. An audit tests whether financial statements are fairly presented. A QoE tests the earnings a buyer and lender rely on, so it goes deeper on add-backs, customers and cash.